The Trader Joe's Edgewater Almost Got — Twice — Just Opened One Stop Away in Uptown

By Socialhood News · Edgewater ·

For Edgewater residents who have spent more than a decade watching Trader Joe's nearly land in their neighborhood — and then not — the wait just got meaningfully shorter. The grocery chain opened its long-anticipated Uptown store on Monday, November 17, at 804 W. Montrose Ave., placing a full Trader Joe's one Red Line stop south of Edgewater's Bryn Mawr station and squarely within the neighborhood's everyday orbit.

The Uptown location is no small milestone: it is, according to the company, the first new Trader Joe's to open in Chicago in six years. The store spans nearly 10,000 square feet, per Block Club Chicago's Madison Savedra, and lands in a stretch of Montrose Avenue that serves as a natural crossroads between Uptown and the neighborhoods directly north, including Edgewater.

The opening carries a particular sting of irony — and perhaps relief — for longtime Edgewater residents. The neighborhood has come frustratingly close to landing Trader Joe's on two separate occasions. In 2015, Edgewater neighbors actively pushed for the chain to open at the former home of El Norte at 5600 N. Ridge Ave., but the company declined; School of Rock now anchors that development. Before that, Trader Joe's was reportedly in talks to open in the strip mall on Broadway just north of Foster Avenue — only to pull out at the last minute, with a PetSmart, Chipotle, and Starbucks ultimately filling the space instead.

With the Uptown store now open, Edgewater residents on the Red Line are within two to three stops of a full Trader Joe's for the first time. The Montrose Avenue address is walkable for residents in the southern reaches of Edgewater, and easily reachable by CTA for anyone farther north along the Broadway corridor. For a neighborhood that prides itself on walkable, transit-connected daily life — and that has spent 2026 watching its own commercial corridors fill with independent restaurants and shops — having Trader Joe's this close fills a genuine grocery gap that many residents have flagged for years.

The timing also adds a practical dimension heading into the holiday cooking season. A Trader Joe's stocked with its signature seasonal items — from the chain's well-regarded pies and prepared sides to its affordable wine and cheese — arrives just as Edgewater households begin planning Thanksgiving tables. The Montrose Avenue location is accessible from the Montrose Red Line stop.

Sources:
1. https://blockclubchicago.org/2026/11/13/trader-joes-uptown-store-opens-monday/

More from Edgewater