Buttercup Brings Italian Café Culture to South Loop with Day-to-Night Amaro Experience

By Socialhood News · Il/Chicago/South Loop · February 15, 2026

South Loop residents have a stylish new destination as Buttercup, a café by day and amaro bar by night, brings a taste of Northern Italy to the neighborhood at 75 E. 16th Street. The 40-seat venue offers a distinctive dual personality, transitioning seamlessly from curated espresso and matcha service during daylight hours to one of the country's largest amaro collections after dark.

Led by beverage director Luke DeYoung, formerly of acclaimed establishments Scofflaw and Oliver's, Buttercup delivers an inventive cocktail program focused on bold yet refined, amaro-forward renditions of classic craft cocktails. The food program, helmed by chef Alex Carnovale, whose impressive resume includes Oliver's and The French Laundry, complements the drinks with elevated Italian fare that pairs perfectly with both daytime coffee service and evening libations.

The concept draws inspiration from Northern Italy's vibrant café culture and traditional Old World amaro bars, creating a unique gathering place for South Loop residents seeking both morning refreshment and sophisticated evening entertainment. Whether you're stopping by for your morning espresso or exploring their extensive amaro selection while enjoying chef Carnovale's Italian cuisine, Buttercup offers a fresh addition to the neighborhood's growing food and beverage scene.

Sources:
1. https://www.modernluxury.com/new-best-restaurants-in-chicago/