Logan Square Is Getting Its First Dedicated Bagel Shop — and It's Doing Things the Chicago Way
By Socialhood News · Logan Square ·
Logan Square has long had no shortage of coffee shops, brunch spots, and neighborhood cafes — but one glaring gap on the morning-food map is finally about to close. The Bagelers, the beloved Chicago-style bagel shop that has been winning over Lincoln Park regulars since it first opened, is expanding to Logan Square in late December, taking over the former Blazed Bakery at 2415 N. Milwaukee Ave. When it opens, it will be the neighborhood's only dedicated bagel shop.
The story behind The Bagelers is a classic one: a Chicagoan set out to find exactly what she wanted and, unable to find it, decided to build it herself. Attorney Sarah Flosi was searching for a quick-service breakfast spot built on made-from-scratch items, high-quality ingredients, and a genuinely homey vibe — and kept coming up empty. So she co-founded The Bagelers with her business partner and brother-in-law Tom Pratl, and the Lincoln Park original became a neighborhood anchor. Now the two are bringing that same ethos to Milwaukee Avenue.
The shop's signature product is a Chicago-style bagel, a category that Flosi is happy to explain. "A Chicago bagel is a little softer and sweeter and less dense than a typical bagel," she told Block Club Chicago. Each one is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked — a labor-intensive process that is very much the point. The Logan Square location will carry the same approach as its older sibling, but it's also adding two new breakfast sandwiches created specifically for the new shop: one built around chorizo, and one featuring pastrami. Both reflect a menu sensibility that nods to Logan Square's own culinary character — the neighborhood has long been a hub for Latin-influenced food and deli traditions alike.
The physical space is being designed with the same warmth as the Lincoln Park original. Flosi updated the original Bagelers with wood accents and a deep green color palette, and that aesthetic will carry over to Milwaukee Avenue. The Logan Square shop will seat 55 guests across booths, tables, and chairs — a size that fits the corner-store-meets-neighborhood-gathering-place feel Flosi has consistently aimed for. Hours will mirror the Lincoln Park location: 7 a.m. to 3 p.m., making it a natural anchor for the morning and midday crowd on a stretch of Milwaukee that sees heavy foot traffic from Blue Line commuters, remote workers, and weekend brunch-seekers alike.
For Flosi, the expansion is also a statement about what kind of businesses Logan Square — and Chicago broadly — needs more of. "Chicago needs family-owned places and we have to keep that alive here," she said. It's a sentiment that lands with particular weight in a neighborhood that has been fielding national chains and large-scale developers in recent years alongside its long-standing independent operators. A family-owned bagel shop opening on Milwaukee Avenue in late December, in a space that has been quiet since Blazed Bakery departed, is exactly the kind of small-business continuity the corridor has been absorbing and celebrating in equal measure.
The timing is also worth noting: The Bagelers' Logan Square debut will land just as the neighborhood's indoor farmers market season gets underway at Avondale Collective a few blocks north, and just weeks before the anticipated early 2027 openings of both a Trader Joe's and a Whole Foods on the same stretch of Milwaukee. Logan Square is entering a period of significant retail transformation — and a hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, family-owned bagel shop arriving in the middle of it feels like exactly the right kind of anchor to have.
The Bagelers Logan Square will open in late December at 2415 N. Milwaukee Ave., with hours of 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. daily. Have you been to The Bagelers in Lincoln Park? Are you excited to see it land in Logan Square — and what do you hope they put on the menu? Share your thoughts with your neighbors on Socialhood.
Sources:
1. https://blockclubchicago.org/2026/11/18/the-bagelers-to-bring-chicago-style-bagels-to-logan-square/